FruityCatOfDoom
07.24.10 | interesting. i like calculating infinity more than miss machine and option paralysis more than both. oceanic is okay but panopticon is better. yeah. other than that less opeth. blackwater is better anyway |
Psilocyanide
07.24.10 | Oceanic is so much better than panopticon. |
fr33convict
07.24.10 | Interesting. I don't like Toxicity that high. |
Alexd93
07.25.10 | I dont like toxicity that high either but allmusic gave it a perfect 5 star rating and i got the most votes on sputnik out of the 20 abums i calculated |
Psilocyanide
07.25.10 | Kinda sounds like the list isn't in your opinion if you're rating something higher because others like it. |
JesusChris
07.25.10 | Needs more Cynic - Traced In Air
Opeth do not deserve two spots. |
eternium
07.25.10 | Acceptable list. |
DoubtGin
07.25.10 | i dont get the (imo) part when you state after that its not your own opinion after all =/ |
Alexd93
07.25.10 | Yeah i thought about that and its really not my opinion but i dont disagree with it too much tho |
Hypochondria
07.25.10 | Interesting but not surprised at all by the results.
Toxicity should be lower IMO |
Alexd93
07.25.10 | ITS NOT MY OPINION!!! SORRY! i spent like all day doing these calculations tho |
Alexd93
07.25.10 | Its somewhat in my opinion tho because i altered it abit...if i wouuldve gone strictly by calculations then toxicity wouldve been number one cuz its rating average was highest and it recieved the most votes on sputnik...but i felt that blackwater was just stronger and that jane doe is simply the best and most powerful album of the decade |
Hypochondria
07.25.10 | Yeah i know, just wanted to add my 2 cents.
good job on the calculations though |
Alexd93
07.25.10 | thanx |
CutMan
07.25.10 | Good list, I say. |
Alexd93
07.25.10 | Just out of curiosity why do you say that? lol |
Hyperion1001
07.25.10 | Put 10 in the 1 spot, leave 5, and replace the rest with better music and you've got a list. |
Jakeitwasaghost
07.25.10 | "ITS NOT MY OPINION!!! SORRY! i spent like all day doing these calculations tho"
Sounds like you wasted your day, pal. |
8bit
07.25.10 | Oceanic is better than Panopticon? |
Locrian
07.25.10 | List needs less Toxicity. |
Smalley
07.25.10 | Yay Agalloch. |
8bit
07.25.10 | WOAH. panopticon got swaped for oceanic! |
TrapThemAlive
08.14.10 | love all of these. Agalloch, Tool and Converge are probably the only ones that would be in my top 10 though |
Alexd93
08.14.10 | Yeah theyre all great, glad to see someone agreeing with this |
Mordecai.
08.14.10 | lol |
IAJP
08.14.10 | a lot of these are really great albums. don't like toxicity though, nor tool. and that kezia album is a bit out of place, despite being pretty good. think jane doe should probably still be on there but much lower. totally know it's been calculated and it's not your opinion but yeah, this is a pretty good list overall. miss machine is amazing, as for isis...panopticon is = to oceanic. both incredible. |
Terrifyer
08.14.10 | terrible. |
Alexd93
08.14.10 | lol i accept your criticisms, you appear to know what your talking about |
Alexd93
08.14.10 | It was somewhat my opinion, i did som emoving around till i felt the list was correct but for the most part its accurate |
Terrifyer
08.14.10 | allmusic is really really bad for metal reviews so I don't know why you used them. You should've used Rate Your Music or Metal Archives really. |
Alexd93
08.14.10 | Im not familiar with them but ill check them out. and i disagree with about allmusic and their metal reviews. |
Terrifyer
08.14.10 | allmusic is ok for mainstream music but for stuff like less-known metal (ie: not these albums) they usually have no idea what they're going on about. i know that most users will back me up on that
on second thoughts Metal-Archives isn't 'good' either cos they don't let most metalcore and alt/nu metal bands on the website |
Alexd93
08.14.10 | I noticed. im gonna create an account for rate your music tho. and give some examples of the "less-known meatl" you were talking about, i may know some. |
IAJP
08.14.10 | allmusic isn't too good for metal reviews, in some respects this site is not so great, the majority of people think opeth / converge / DeP are the extent of metal and no more, obviously that's not true but if you use a site which uses mean ranking, more people are going to vote on stuff they know, so the better and more obscure metal gets buried. not to say that opeth/converge/DeP aren't all amazing, they are, but i think if you asked the metal listeners of this site to compile a top ten it would be different to this, maybe different albums, maybe different artists, but it would be more comprehensive. maybe metal archives woulda been better..but i have to say alex, i do commend you for doing this, it must have took some fair old time to do! |
Alexd93
08.14.10 | Thank you! after checking out some other sites im gonna do another list of this, with alot more ratings and calculations. i understand what you mean tho. its took me likes two hours i think, idr. |
greg84
08.14.10 | Neat idea. I think you should have left the things unchanged. Adding your preference kind of defies the purpose. Toxicity is my favorite album form here closely followed by Lateralus. |
Alexd93
08.15.10 | I dont think toxicity should be that high...i even think lateralus is a bit high but they're both good |
KILL
08.15.10 | so tired of seeing jane doe plastered everywhere on this site ugh |
Alexd93
08.15.10 | Its just an amazing album |
mojolukasmojo
08.25.10 | 2=ewww |
maidenpmcc
08.25.10 | List need's Iron Maiden. |
Terrifyer
08.25.10 | lol the list is bad enough already |
LordHelmet
08.25.10 | List needz moar Saving Abel. |
Terrifyer
08.25.10 | |
Inveigh
08.25.10 | god damn comment deleter |
Terrifyer
08.25.10 | i just tried to delete all of josh's comments but it doesn't work |
Terrifyer
08.25.10 | fuckin timezones
how do they work |
climactic
08.25.10 | 2 > 1 |
Terrifyer
08.25.10 | im in the UK so im like 5-6 hours ahead or something |
ShoeSoup
08.25.10 | 2 is uberfail. low point in their once glorious career. very very unfortunate. even 3 is better than it. 5 decimates the living poonflesh out of everything on the entire list though. obv the rest suck, especially 1 |
Alexd93
08.26.10 | Did someone seriously tell me to put saving abel on this list? Jesus christ thats sad. |
Alexd93
08.26.10 | Did someone seriously tell me to put saving abel on this list? Jesus christ thats sad. |
zarquan99
09.11.10 | Discordance Axis - The Inalienable Dreamless
Between the Buried and Me - Colors
Cynic - Traced in Air
Decapitated - Winds of Creation
a couple I might add... |
Dryden
09.11.10 | fuck daylight savings |
Alexd93
09.12.10 | Colors wasnt that good |
EnCrypt.
09.12.10 | Gay list and woah I didnt not expect half of these and I definitely didnt expect 1 and 2 |
Ire
09.12.10 | ... well at least you got #1 right. |
NeutralThunder12
09.12.10 | nah colors was that good. Also needs Traced in Air |
Ire
09.12.10 | ya totally...
I'm agreeing with progmaster.. oh god something's wrong with me. |
NeutralThunder12
09.12.10 | no I'm just right. Traced in Air was one of the best metal albums this decade. List needs Colors and Bath definitely. List is pretty cliche for the most part but there are still some awesome records on here. |
ShadowRemains
09.12.10 | immo or gtfo |
Ire
09.12.10 | Close To A World Below is probably my 3rd favorite metal album of the decade.
|
NeutralThunder12
09.12.10 | I actually prefer a lot of the prog/metalcore bands over bands like Isis and Tool, SikTh and The Faceless would prolly be on mine. Can't get into post-metal |
JackIsA
07.27.11 | why do people hate on soad they are just close minded |
