NeutralThunder12
10.06.10 | generic list is generic. 5 sucks btw i put it there as a joke |
BigHans
10.06.10 | yeah it does |
NeutralThunder12
10.06.10 | nice but you know you love 10 and 4 |
geng
10.06.10 | If you hate Colours so much why have you got it as a 5 on your ratings? |
BigHans
10.06.10 | I love 2, 4, 7, and 10.
1 is good, 3 is massively overrated, 5 sucks, havent heard 6 or 8, 9 is good in the sense they are talented but zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
Just wrote like you bro |
iPim
10.06.10 | I'm just gonna say this; Metallica is the most overrated band EVER to exist |
geng
10.06.10 | I'm just gonna say this; Metallica is the most overrated band EVER to exist.
Iron Maiden? |
BigHans
10.06.10 | I'm just gonna say this; Metallica is the most overrated band EVER to exist
^ or maybe you're just an idiot |
NeutralThunder12
10.06.10 | haha, yes you did.
But if you think Godspeed You! are boring than you can't appreciate quality composition and must have the attention span of a rodent |
Apollo
10.06.10 | If you think Iron Maiden is overrated you might be retarded
|
NeutralThunder12
10.06.10 | "I'm just gonna say this; Metallica is the most overrated band EVER to exist."
lol
And I don't know if your saying that Iron Maiden is equally overrated, or If I like them. To answer that possible question, if this was a top 25 list, Powerslave would prolly be like 14 or 15.
|
iPim
10.06.10 | ^ or maybe you're just an idiot
And even then you have to agree that they are the biggest dicks EVER to exist. Fuck metallica |
Apollo
10.06.10 | And Godspeed is terrible |
BigHans
10.06.10 | Metallica and Maiden are the two greatest metal bands in history. Period. End of discussion. |
geng
10.06.10 | I was saying Maiden are more overrated. Then again I'm somewhat biased being that I hate them. |
Apollo
10.06.10 | gotcha |
NeutralThunder12
10.06.10 | well you have 3 Tool albums 5'd
so your opinion doesn't matter |
geng
10.06.10 | I do love Sputnik |
Apollo
10.06.10 | only one Tool album is worthy of being 5'd
also Godspeed sucks [2] |
BigHans
10.06.10 | I can appreciate the quality of the composition of Godspeed, Im just not a fan of 25 minute songs. |
iPim
10.06.10 | I love Iron Maiden, they never went through a st. anger phase. How can a band be so loved when it hasn't brought out a good album since like what, 1990? |
NeutralThunder12
10.06.10 | only 0 Tool albums worthy of being a 5 |
BigHans
10.06.10 | How can a band be so loved when it hasn't brought out a good album since like what, 1990?
^ Because they put out 2, possibly 3 of the greatest metal albums ever made, and 2 other undeniable classics. Thats why. |
iPim
10.06.10 | Yeah, I turned this into a ''most overrated'' discussion |
NeutralThunder12
10.06.10 | "How can a band be so loved when it hasn't brought out a good album since like what, 1990?"
Because their first four albums was the best career run that a metal band ever had
now get out of my list and proceed jacking off to Maynard James Keenan |
iPim
10.06.10 | ''^ Because they put out 2, possibly 3 of the greatest metal albums ever made, and 2 other undeniable classics. Thats why.''
There are countless other classics that are way better than metallica's so called ''classiscs''. Death, Cryptopsy, Converge, Botch, Megadeth, Iron Maiden, Opeth. Just random bands that have put out better material than Metallica ever has or will |
geng
10.06.10 | I agree with Hans that 3 isn't as good as a lot of people seem to think it is. Saying that normally gets you crucified on here. |
Apollo
10.06.10 | Metallica is massively overrated, I agree with that. That being said Ride The Lightning and Master of Puppets are easily in the top ten best metal albums ever created. |
Apollo
10.06.10 | lol at Converge being better than Metallica.
Converge fucking suck |
iPim
10.06.10 | Hey, I never said Tool was the greatest band on the planet! |
DoubtGin
10.06.10 | also Godspeed rules [3] |
NeutralThunder12
10.06.10 | "Death, Cryptopsy, Converge, Botch, Megadeth, Iron Maiden, Opeth. Just random bands that have put out better material than Metallica ever has or will"
judging by the tone, I'm questioning if iPim is my alter ego, he's a douchebag like me who has no idea what he's talking about |
iPim
10.06.10 | Let's be friends then |
geng
10.06.10 | Lol @ Converge sucking |
Apollo
10.06.10 | you just called yourself a douchebag proggy
|
Apollo
10.06.10 | Lol @ Metallica sucking
Converge is awful and easily the most overrated band on this site next to Gayspeed You! Black Fagperor |
BigHans
10.06.10 | "Death, Cryptopsy, Converge, Botch, Megadeth, Iron Maiden, Opeth. Just random bands that have put out better material than Metallica ever has or will"
^ Funniest thing I will see all week probably. |
iPim
10.06.10 | And so did he |
iPim
10.06.10 | I also hate metallica because I still have to pay 15 euro's for an album that has been put out about 30 years ago, while I can buy any Iron Maiden album for 5 bucks easily. Metallica is ready to get your cash, they're money whores |
geng
10.06.10 | I never said Metallica sucked. You're right about MOP and RTL. |
Apollo
10.06.10 | Maybe thats how it works in Europe but in North America its the opposite. Maiden albums go for $25 or more. I can buy MOP or AJFA for $10 here |
NeutralThunder12
10.06.10 | "you just called yourself a douchebag proggy"
yep. And iPim is beyond retarded he should stop now |
BigHans
10.06.10 | He actually makes you look smart Proggy, and that is NOT easy to do. |
Inveigh
10.06.10 | this thread is full of hilarity |
iPim
10.06.10 | Hilarity ensues... |
Inveigh
10.06.10 | well i mean saying that you like megadeth but hate metallica is kind of dumb, unless you openly admit that your metallica hatred has nothing to do with their music. |
taroo
10.06.10 | lots of good stuff here, but 1 is only thing I 5'd |
geng
10.06.10 | I really need to get round to listening to 1. 21st Century Schizoid Man is great. |
fr33convict
10.06.10 | lol u gaiz |
SeaAnemone
10.06.10 | man some people take music pretty seriously, huh? |
Jesuslaves
10.06.10 | 2 is such a drag. |
iPim
10.06.10 | ''well i mean saying that you like megadeth but hate metallica is kind of dumb, unless you openly admit that your metallica hatred has nothing to do with their music.''
Father, I have a confession to make...
Yes, my hatred is mostly for the members of the band. Not so much their music. I like their 4 essential album, but I'm not really the thrash guy.
|
Inveigh
10.06.10 | iPim: fair enough |
fr33convict
10.06.10 | Metallica has always been better than Megadeth atleast to me. But the lack of no one bringing up Black Sabbath in the top 3
metal bands ever is pretty scary. |
BigHans
10.06.10 | Sabbath is number 3 IMO. |
Inveigh
10.06.10 | we were discussing top 3 metal bands ever? |
iPim
10.06.10 | ''we were discussing top 3 metal bands ever?''
well, we were discussing overrated bands in a ''best of'' list... |
Deathcar
10.06.10 | Maiden, Metallica, GY!BE and Converge are all overrated, but that doesn't mean they're not all damned awesome...it's just the way they get hyped on various website etc., it'd be impossible for them to not be. |
Nagrarok
10.06.10 | 1,4 & 10 rule
...
...
5 sucks. |
NeutralThunder12
10.06.10 | haha thanks Nag but you don't like modern metal for the most part so where are you to talk haha |
BigHans
10.06.10 | 5 sucks [2] |
Inveigh
10.06.10 | this is a "best of" list? |
NeutralThunder12
10.06.10 | hans doesnt like music with talent, and has never even listened to a BTBAM album in full
and @Inveigh its my top 10 albums of all time currently |
Nagrarok
10.06.10 | 'but you don't like modern metal for the most part'
You have me all wrong there. I dislike bad modern metal. |
Inveigh
10.06.10 | haha I know, iPim said we were on a best of list, whereas I'm pretty sure your description clearly says this is your 10 favorite albums |
NeutralThunder12
10.06.10 | name some modern metal bands (particularly similar to BTBAM, such as the other experimental metalcore bands) that you are a fan of. Not bashing you at all, just saying looking at your ratings at least, you don't seem to be at all a metalcore/hardcore prog guy, so its not surprising that you don't like BTBAM. |
BigHans
10.06.10 | and has never even listened to a BTBAM album in full
^ I have. 2 of them. And it was fucking painful both times. And considering I share 3 of your top ten favorite artists, you should probably think twice about that bands with talent comment retard. |
NeutralThunder12
10.06.10 | i''m talking about experimental music bands, whom you have bashed constantly because their music is to intricate for
your gay little glam metal brain. Its also funny when you make fun of Converge, I enjoy that. |
Nagrarok
10.06.10 | metalcore/hardcore does not equal modern metal. Of course I admit I like my metal served old school better, but I'm open to pretty much anything. Colours was just way too pretentious, and the vocals made me cringe. |
NeutralThunder12
10.06.10 | King Crimson/Robert Fripp is/was about 10 times more pretentious than BTBAM will ever be.
Now tell me I'm wrong.
And your right, metalcore/hardcore does not equal modern metal, but seeing as you have little-no metalcore/hardcore prog rated, I'm sensing that you never had a hope of liking BTBAM any way to be honest. |
iPim
10.06.10 | ''this is a "best of" list?''
I meant ''favorite album'', excuse me for my stupidness |
NeutralThunder12
10.06.10 | you are excused |
Inveigh
10.06.10 | i'm still thinking about it |
Nagrarok
10.06.10 | 'King Crimson/Robert Fripp is/was about 10 times more pretentious than BTBAM will ever be.'
Ah, but the difference is they could actually pull off some fantastic albums. Namely: ITCOTKK, Red, Discipline, and to a lesser extent Lizard & Larks' Tongues. |
Apollo
10.06.10 | Agreed with Nag and Hans about BTBAM. I've listened to Colors and Alaska a couple times and did not like them one bit. Selkies is the only song I thought was good |
iPim
10.06.10 | I personally also am not the biggest fan of Colors too, I prefer Alaska. But I believe that that wasn't the subject of this discussion |
kangaroopoo
10.07.10 | AJFA + B.Park in my 10 best, 4 maybe, 5 not quite. |
