NWOAHM666
10.26.11 | Discuss |
AsoTamaki
10.26.11 | Negative reaction. LOL @ New American Gospel being on a list of top anything. |
Crysis
10.26.11 | I mean if you see three mastodon albums on a list you know the list automatically sucks |
Wheelah
10.26.11 | Not bad, though there are better albums. Too much Killswitch and Lamb of God. |
NWOAHM666
10.26.11 | Gospel is my personal fav LoG album and I think that it helped to shape the deathcore genre. However, it's a 2000 release, so it can't be in the list. |
SpiritCrusher2
10.26.11 | too much american metal |
Keyblade
10.26.11 | Just no. Apparently As the Palace Burns is better than BwP. This list has got nothing on Metal
Hammer's top 25 debut albums though where Slipknot's s/t is #1 and Cowboys from Hell was up there too.
Mind you, none of these being their debuts (Cowboys is like Pantera's 4th album lol). But BfMV's debut
being on that list took the cake. |
Ovrot
10.26.11 | lol what
list is lols |
NWOAHM666
10.26.11 | @Keyblade33: I think that the fact that LP were in that list, alongside with Slipknot and Pantera bringing, respectively, their 2nd and 4th CDs to the party were the points that truly took the cake. |
Keyblade
10.26.11 | Well their excuse was it was their major label debut, so lol. No excuses for B4MV though. I mean, I
can understand Hybrid Theory being on there to an extent, but come on. |
Zorak
10.26.11 | any LoG over Opeth is just wrong. |
anarchistfish
10.26.11 | 21, 11 and 5 belong
rest can foad
also
"too much american metal"
this^ |
AsoTamaki
10.26.11 | *chooses three American metal bands*
rest can foad
too much american metal |
anarchistfish
10.26.11 | well when most of the list is american obviously there's a high chance that all the ones I'll like from it will be american |
endtell
10.26.11 | 1, 3, 5, 8, 9, 11, 12, 13, 14 are good, but some aren't really metal, and the rest of the list is full of average american albums. |
ILJ
10.26.11 | Terrible list.
Also, making a "best of 21st century" anything when we still have more than 88 years left is ridiculous. Maybe they should have made it a "best of decade" list. |
Inveigh
10.26.11 | lol like half this list is made up of three bands. and those three bands are Mastodon, Killswitch Engage and Lamb of God. |
KILL5
10.26.11 | lol |
anarchistfish
10.26.11 | 17 made me lol |
CrazyPlane
10.26.11 | Some good, mostly boring. |
Ire
10.26.11 | Seeing Jane Doe sandwiched in between those two shitty album makes me :/ |
NWOAHM666
10.26.11 | ^Do you realize the historical importance of #4?!
"Also, making a 'best of 21st century' anything when we still have more than 88 years left is ridiculous. Maybe they should have made it a 'best of decade' list."
"lol like half this list is made up of three bands. and those three bands are Mastodon, Killswitch Engage and Lamb of God."
+1
That's why usually these lists are limited to one per band, but MetalSucks decided to forget that rule.
Also note that Opeth also have 2 records. |
BaseballJames
10.26.11 | MetalSucks is a terrible website, and Axl Rosenberg sucks Dallas Coyle off every night. Fact. |
RobotJesus
10.26.11 | Don't forget the fact that Metalsucks is elitist as fuck |
turnip90210
10.26.11 | Ayup, the situation is bad. So, when does metal snap out of the rut it's in? |
YetAnotherBrick
10.26.11 | Get Lamb of God, Slipknot, Shadows Fall, Hatebreed, and Killswitch off the list altogether. Holy crap, this list blows. |
someguest
10.26.11 | isn't Thor writing for this website now?
lmfao |
foxblood
10.26.11 | disgusting list |
MO
10.26.11 | yea this is so bad hahahaha |
Ire
10.26.11 | 4 is important to people that suck |
TheNotrap
10.26.11 | Needs Behemoth, Nevermore, Megadeth and Testament |
MO
10.26.11 | Needs Meshuggah and Neurosis hard. |
acorncheese
10.26.11 | LOL THIS IS FUNNY |
AfterTheBreakdown
10.26.11 | gross |
Emim
10.26.11 | "Gospel is my personal fav LoG album and I think that it helped to shape the deathcore genre."
whatthefuckamireading |
ultradevilgod
10.26.11 | Hahaha what a corny list! |
Aids
10.26.11 | no wonder they think metal sucks |
Relinquished
10.26.11 | "4 is important to people that suck"
lol shut up
"Needs Meshuggah and Neurosis hard."
it wouldn't save the list
|
RooseveltsGhost
10.26.11 | Fprget the fact that Lamb of God is not a top-tier metal band, the list contains Ashes of the Wake, New American Gospel and As the Palaces Burn, but not Sacrament. |
EyesWideShut
10.26.11 | replace Opeth and Converge with Slayer, Megadeth, or more LOG. |
MO
10.26.11 | "it wouldn't save the list"
At least it would somewhat make them seem like they know what they're talking about. |
EyesWideShut
10.26.11 | na bro it would just damage the rep of Meshu and Neurosis. |
DeadBeat
10.26.11 | This is so fucking bad, even the worst Opeth album is better than the best Lamb Of God album
1 is awesome though |
FeralMemories
10.26.11 | This list was made from a bunch of different guys making top 21 lists, and then taking the ones that appeared the most times into the final one. Obviously, it was gonna play out as a popularity contest instead of which albums actually were the best. They also really needed to reduce it to one album per band cause this is 14 bands on a 21 album list, 2 of which appear THREE times. List overall = fail. |
FilthyBorgir
10.26.11 | lol @ hatebreed |
FilthyBorgir
10.26.11 | Edge of Sanity - Crimson 2
Iron Maiden - Brave New World
Dark Tranquillity - Character/DD/Fiction.
there's too many to keep going on. |
Ire
10.26.11 | wow that is the worst username i've ever seen |
Emim
10.27.11 | I smell a moaropeth series! |
DeafMetal
10.27.11 | shittiest metal list evr |
twlight
10.27.11 | horrible list |
pedro70512
10.27.11 | MASTODOMINATION
Ghost Reveries is my favorite Opeth album. The list has a bunch of "uh...?" moments but I'm not complaining. |
NWOAHM666
10.31.11 | Come on, besides the ridiculous band repetitions, the list ain't that bad.
@FilthyBorgir:
I heard that Brave New World was like...bad beyond bad... |
SmokingTheClouds
10.31.11 | Metalsucks sucks at making metal list.
Though, I appreciate the inclusion of both 10 & 9. This list reminds me of their "Top 25 Modern Metal Guitar Players", when they said Nile & Avenged Sevenfold had better guitarist than Scale the Summit. |
Hawks
10.31.11 | This list is fucking ridiculous. |
coneren
10.31.11 | that means gay right |
WeepingBanana
10.31.11 | needs moar boris |