Papa Universe: EMO CROWN 2: Decision making thread

Papa Universe 08.15.17	Let's talk
Conmaniac 08.15.17	yes lets...
ianblxdsoe 08.15.17	howdy ho friendo
Papa Universe 08.15.17	First, let's start with the management. Then we'll decide upon the individual roles, from which we can develop some rules.
Conmaniac 08.15.17	also yea read 5 if u gonna be a judge u gotta be o n u r s h i t
Papa Universe 08.15.17	Drifter was a good sport when he was in, but I will not tolerate the same turn again.
Conmaniac 08.15.17	I think since Deadly is managing the Post Punk comp we should have one of these other 4 potential judges take over
Papa Universe 08.15.17	Ian, are you in for the judge's part?
clavier 08.15.17	hello hello, I am here
Conmaniac 08.15.17	welcome! any ideas on the matters at hand?
Papa Universe 08.15.17	Pick a side then, judge or competitor?
Papa Universe 08.15.17	6 people, 3 judges and 3 competitors. Does that sound good?
Drifter 08.15.17	"And I MUST make sure that everyone, who says they're in is going to actually commit. No "I thought it'll be fun at first" bullshit, no "I am not interested in it anymore" fuckery, you are in for a longrun" Hey
Conmaniac 08.15.17	I think Ian should be a competitor because he knows almost as much emo as me. rest should be judges
Drifter 08.15.17	Also 1 is a good album everyone should check
Conmaniac 08.15.17	drifter get out of here its time for the adults to talk
Papa Universe 08.15.17	oh snap
Drifter 08.15.17	Ok ;-;
clavier 08.15.17	I'd like to be a judge
Papa Universe 08.15.17	I need a direct confirmation from Ian that he'll be a competitor and an approval from sincerelyaural and Frivolous that they are okay with assuming the roles of judges.
Papa Universe 08.15.17	Oh crap, I forgot about LandDiving
neekafat 08.15.17	How many rounds is this going to?
Conmaniac 08.15.17	I think Friv and Deadly would also make good judges. Jack im nervous about though because he has a ton of emo he's heard that he just hasnt rated...ian could be a competitor, obv same with unique and me and Asleep can be a celeb wild card judge (talk about this later)
Papa Universe 08.15.17	So is Jack a competitor then?
Papa Universe 08.15.17	neekafat, you want to go in?
clavier 08.15.17	i've discussed the details with con, i'll be fine with judging
Frivolous 08.15.17	yeah i'm good with judging. i don't know a whole lot about emo so this should be interesting
ZombieToyDuck 08.15.17	damn shits finally gettin real its bout time
Conmaniac 08.15.17	idk should jack be a competitor? 4 albums per dayish?
verdant 08.15.17	I WILL BE A JUDGE IF NEED BE
Conmaniac 08.15.17	ok thanks so 4 confirmed judges: Friv, Claire, Jack, and Deadly rn only 2 confirmed competitors: Con, Unique
bgillesp 08.15.17	Who won the first one?
Papa Universe 08.15.17	Nobody did yet, we are making part 2, because one of the two judges (and the administrator of the competition) bolted.
Papa Universe 08.15.17	I mean I had like 0.2 lead against Conmaniac, but that doesn't mean a lot now.
Conmaniac 08.15.17	yep he "won" by .2 but we were cut off mid round so its hard to say.
Papa Universe 08.15.17	But you know...technicalities
Conmaniac 08.15.17	hence this part 2! the end all be all!
Papa Universe 08.15.17	Can I at least get a 0.2 boost for my somewhat deserved unpronounced victory?
Conmaniac 08.15.17	it's there for you to take or leave Unique
Papa Universe 08.15.17	I shall take
Conmaniac 08.15.17	fair enough, could be important. do we have anything finalized yet though?
Joeman82 08.15.17	I would be a judge, but I feel like 4 people is already hard enough to find an album that all of them haven't listened to ya know?
Conmaniac 08.15.17	truth man, gonna be a tricky comp. plus even tho I trust u all its gonna just get harder to coordinate between people once we add more judges
Joeman82 08.15.17	I'm interested in being one, I just don't want it to a clusterfuck tr;dl
Papa Universe 08.15.17	Joeman can be a judge, but that'll mena that we will push LandDiving into competitors ring, cause he's the most flexible one.
Joeman82 08.15.17	Ask LD first but I'd be down with that.
clavier 08.15.17	we'll need to make sure everyone is alright with 4 albums per round then
clavier 08.15.17	also, who indeed would be best at managing the thread?
Conmaniac 08.15.17	yeah 4 albums per round seems like a lot to ask...
Joeman82 08.15.17	If it's too hard then I don't have to participate. Like I said I don't want to make things complicated.
Conmaniac 08.15.17	PERSONALLY for the sake of keeping this a quicker format I'd prefer 2 competitors (maybe 3 I guess) and at an absolute max 6 judges but thats just my 2 cents
Papa Universe 08.15.17	If Joeman isn't in, then we have 4 judges and 3 comps. Does that sound alright?
Conmaniac 08.15.17	who is the third competitor? Ian?
Papa Universe 08.15.17	yeah, seems so
clavier 08.15.17	yeah, it's ian
Conmaniac 08.15.17	can he confirm or deny this and should we get rid of the .2 lead then since ian wasnt in the comp last round?
Papa Universe 08.15.17	Shout Ian And you just want to strip me of my victory, don't you?
Artuma 08.15.17	can i play some kind of a role in this please? i don't even care which role, i just wanna be accepted :[
Conmaniac 08.15.17	shit yeah Art should be a competitor honestly
Artuma 08.15.17	yay i love competitions :]
Conmaniac 08.15.17	seeing as ian dropped his own rec competition after 1 round im not sure we can trust his dedication
Papa Universe 08.15.17	So we can replace Ian with Art, if Ian's fine... also Joeman wanted to play a role in this.
Conmaniac 08.15.17	yeah I think he wants to be a judge...3 competitors 5 judges?
clavier 08.15.17	would be great to have Art as a competitor, i have heard good things of his taste
Conmaniac 08.15.17	if im being honest he's the true king of the genre so some tough competition
Artuma 08.15.17	i can already feel the pressure
Papa Universe 08.15.17	Okay, Art, you're in.
Papa Universe 08.15.17	Moving Ian into judges then?
ianblxdsoe 08.15.17	whatever you guys want me to do man
Papa Universe 08.15.17	I'd rather keep an even amount of judges and competitors, but it seems like the other judges can't handle 4 albums at once (also seeing as some of them have their own tourneys to keep up with). So that means that you're a judge now. That means that we now have 5 judges and 3 competitors. Alright?
Conmaniac 08.15.17	yeah 3 albums is do able trust me I'm doing that right now for the post punk thing hahah.
clavier 08.15.17	i'm fine with 5 judges and 3 competitors
ZombieToyDuck 08.15.17	sounds gooooooood
Papa Universe 08.15.17	So the roles are determined. Now, who's going to be the admin? We need someone from the judges, who's there all the time.
Papa Universe 08.15.17	Frivolous has only one list posted, but sincerelyaural seems like a more responsible admin. That is of those, who don't currently run any tourneys or series.
ianblxdsoe 08.15.17	to be fair con finding 25 mostly obscure songs and having them be on so many different platforms and not being able to compile them into one playlist is way harder than just listening to 2 albums a day
Papa Universe 08.15.17	By the way, you're a judge.
Conmaniac 08.15.17	true ian!
ianblxdsoe 08.16.17	okay i'm fine with judging
clavier 08.16.17	hm, alright, I guess I can admin if no one else wants to
Papa Universe 08.16.17	So that's settled then. Judges: DeadlyNightShade, sincerelyaural, Frivolous, LandDiving, ianblxdsoe Competitors: Conmaniac, UniqueUniverse, Artuma Administrator: sincerelyaural
clavier 08.16.17	let's agree on/finalize rules before i make the thread
Papa Universe 08.16.17	I suppose it'll be just like Part 1. The competitors submit their albums, the judges listen, make write-ups, post it, then the next round all over again. Except we will make a new thread for each Round, just like Post-Punk-off, cause only one will quickly run out of space with this many participants.
Papa Universe 08.16.17	However, to make it interesting, I propose that every new round, one of the judges will come up with a restriction or a criteria the submitted albums have to follow. That way we can keep the contest more challenging.
clavier 08.16.17	That sounds like a cool idea, I'd be down for that
Conmaniac 08.16.17	yeah 1st round lets keep simple tho