">
 

Pink Floyd
Atom Heart Mother


3.0
good

Review

by pulseczar USER (67 Reviews)
October 25th, 2005 | 117 replies


Release Date: 1970 | Tracklist


The members of Pink Floyd have two sets of children. One of them is the result of gettin' it on. The latter is a result of going into a studio and recording a bunch of songs. Now generally parents don't play favourites with their litter, but poor little Atom Heart Mother has been singled out by them as one of their worst albums. So is this album the wino that's too lazy to move out, out of the children? In the Pink Floyd's eyes, yes. But really, Atom Heart Mother isn't that much of a lazy alcoholic. Despite the Floyd's dislike, the album isn't as bad as it's painted by various sources, and is certainly not the worst Pink Floyd album.

Atom Heart Mother was released in 1970, Pink Floyd still in their experimental prime and ready to tinker even more with modern music. After Syd Barrett was kicked out in 1968, Pink Floyd found it hard to construct solid albums and to match the success of their debut and the singles formed by Barrett. Releasing increasingly experimental and sprawling avant-garde works, Pink Floyd were struggling for a new sound but testing stuff out at the same time. So Pink Floyd released an album with their wackiest songs to date and with more mature songs. Oh those crazy kids.

If you describe Atom Heart Mother with one word, well, the point is you wouldn't be able to (words like "pwngasmic" or "piece-o-***" don't count). Though the album is considered to be very experimental, it contains calm, bare songs like If. If is surprisingly the only Roger Waters song on the album, it's a quietly sung song starting the mostly acoustic theme on the album. Roger's voice is much more grounded and proper than the goofy singing the bass player made on earlier songs. The gloomy guitar solo doesn't add a whole lot to the song, Gilmour plays a much better, perhaps one of his best, in the otherwise boring Fat Old Sun. Fat Old Sun is also a quiet acoustic song, but not nearly as interesting or melodious as If. Those songs aren't varied at all, but rest assured, Atom Heart Mother has some wack shiznit, perhaps even wackier than its title.

Like 1971's Meddle, Atom Heart Mother stands out for a single song. That song is the monstrous, pretentious, perplexing, Atom Heart Mother. Compiled of 6 parts and totaling 23 minutes, you can expect a spectacle, love it or hate it. To love it or hate it, this is many times the case when it comes to Floyd fans' opinions of this song. With subsections with names like Breast Milky and Funky Dung, you may ask yourself how out of it were Pink Floyd at this time. The music might just answer that question for you. Whether it'd be writing songs compiled mostly of noise making or just straight up Rock, you never knew what Pink Floyd were going to do. They get a little help from their friends here, getting an entire orchestra and an avant-garde compose to make this scattered epic. Driven mainly by what's been described as a "recycled Western movie theme" by the members, Atom Heart Mother begins with a very catchy chord progression lead by the horn sections. But the whole concept of keeping a 23 minute song lead by one chord progression is quickly chucked out; Atom Heart Mother changes rather suddenly and awkwardly throughout the song, making the song less enjoyable and seems even more directionless.

Perhaps the smoothest section is d. Funky Dung, it quickly changes the theme to a, well, funky piece, ditching all the orchestra gobbledygook as Waters dishes out a funky bassline. Roger Waters isn't really a good bassist, clearly enjoying to play something else when given the chance. It's rare that a progressive rock band doesn't have a kick-ass bass player, but that's Floyd for you. Even guitarist David Gilmour proves to be a better one, but Waters is still good. As he plays the bassline, keyboardist Rick Wright lays out equally funky organ playing, as Gilmour struts his stuff, playing an improvised sounding solo. Funky Dung then takes a strange turn, as the choir members start chanting random words (I doubt if some of them are real ones), the whole thing builds up until re-introducing the main theme again. After that the song falls apart completely, going through a strange interlude of noises and previous themes, essentially ruining a possibly perfect ending. And that's only around 15 minutes. Atom Heart Mother then loses my interest completely as it starts to repeat itself after the pointlessly weird interlude, dragging out the song way too much. I still enjoy listening to it, I think this album is underrated, but the song could've been reduced greatly.

Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast rivals the title track as most bewildering song on Atom Heart Mother. No, the song title does have a meaning, because the song really is about Alan having breakfast. Alan the roadie has breakfast while Pink Floyd noodle around with their instruments for 11 minutes. Mostly Wright's piano and Gilmour's guitar play around while Alan smacks his lips after taking bites of toast, cooking some eggs and mumbling stuff to himself. Don't dismiss it so quickly, as many have, the music is actually pretty good, but granted, gets boring after a while. The last part of it c. Morning Glory, is the best, all the little themes and noodling come together to end one of the strangest instrumentals ever.

Atom Heart Mother isn't a very easy album to get into, specifically Atom Heart Mother and Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast. I really don't recommend this album to anyone trying to start out with Pink Floyd, unless you like music that's really out there. As for me, this is the second Floyd album that I listened to, I actually that it was awesome. ***ing weird, but awesome. There is one track here that does instantly appeal and is very fun, though is very un-Floydian. Summer '68 is a Beach Boysesque upbeat Rick Wright song, probably one of the poppiest Floyd songs ever. It's about Wright banging groupies and whatnot, with menacing sounding horn interludes and a chorus consisting of 'How do you feel? Ba ba ba bada da da da da da da da da'. Though Atom Heart Mother is puzzling, messy, experimental, it's good when you give it a chance, but has it's shares of weak spots. The fun thing about such a varied, crazy album is that you won't get bored of most of it any time soon. And remember, love all your children equally... or at least pretend to.

Atom Heart Mother------------> 3 stars



Recent reviews by this author
Pharoahe Monch DesireEl-P I'll Sleep When You're Dead
Jaylib Champion SoundMF DOOM MM.. Food
RZA Afro Samurai SoundtrackEloy Inside
user ratings (2089)
3.6
great
other reviews of this album
1 of


Comments:Add a Comment 
Zebra
Moderator
October 25th 2005


2647 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

I'm glad someone reviewed this. I think this is album is a complete mess, but in all fairness your review was excellent, nice work.

Arrakakaka
October 26th 2005


685 Comments


I listen to Pink Floyd from time to time. I've heard a few songs off of this, yet they're alright.

And that cow is like, "Fuck me."

Jawaharal
October 26th 2005


1832 Comments


pwngasmic review Galapwngos.

Jawaharal
October 26th 2005


1832 Comments


And that cow is like, "Fuck me."

:lol:

november, octember
October 26th 2005


14 Comments


Hey. Just to let you know u did a great job of reviewing this album. Personally, as a thirteen year old floyd fan, i think this is a great album. The first album i ever heard of pink floyd was wish you were here. then animals and dark side. Then, i heard this. i sat through the first song. thought it was great at parts, odd at others, and then i heard if, fat old sun, and what really jumped out at me, summer 68. Totally different from most later floyd, similar to saucer full of secrets, and over all awesome. Alan's psychedelic breakfast, however, i'm still trying to like.

guitarded_chuck
November 26th 2005


18070 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I really dig this album at times. Fat Old Sun is pretty underrated. I love the solo in the song.

pfandozzyrock
December 26th 2005


40 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

If you are a newer floyd fan i would think you wouldnt like Atom heart mother , IT takes years of listening of floyud aND understanding of the band and what they went through to appreciate this piece of art. It isnt the worste thing you could possibly listen to but it also yea isnt the greatest. Its floyd and i love it no matter what its not the "poppy" darkside stuff but its good material and everyone that claims they are fans should aprreciate their trouble.

pulseczar
February 9th 2006


2385 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I've heard all of their "art". As for everything else you said; you're an arrogant idiot.

Its all gravys
February 13th 2006


2 Comments


personally i love this album. i feel that the song atom heart mother flows well. of course its strange at some points but then again isnt most floyd a little strange? listening to it from the view point of a bassist the funky dung piece i think is brilliant, its so groovey. lol. why does everyone think roger waters is such a terrible bassist.... i think hes pretty good myself.... maybey not because of his technical prowess but for the lines, riffs and fills he comes up with like in the funky dung piece.

forty-two
April 5th 2006


5 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I really like atom heart mother, though it's strange in many ways.

Maybe I like it just because of it's strangeness.

If and Fat Old Sun are not bad, but I can't stand Summer '68, it's the worst thing, Richard Wright has ever done. And I hate to hear people eating ... so I dislike Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast, though the instrumental parts are very cool and relaxing.



But, because Atom Heart Mother is the song that makes the album, (the other ones are just B-sides, imo) , the whole thing get's an 4.5/5

Jimmy
April 21st 2006


736 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I like Atom Heart Mother a lot. The opening suite is very enjoyable and each of the three middle songs have the strengths (especially Fat Old Sun.) Alan's is probably the weakest part.



Overall a 4 I suppose.

Blackbird
June 2nd 2006


39 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

This album is a lot better than it is made out to be.



- Summer 68

- Fat Old Sun

- If



Are all gems

irishslappop
June 4th 2006


2 Comments


summer of 68 is one of my favorite songs of all time, not to mention fat old sun, which is musical sex. highly underrated album.

nbeachbum222
October 11th 2006


2 Comments


Floyd is awesome, do not insult them.

ubermensch518
February 5th 2009


52 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

That was a really well done review

shindip
May 19th 2009


3539 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

he first 4 minutes of alans psychadelic breakfast are... psychadelic

Dragonforce89
February 14th 2010


332 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Thier best.

ghigno92
March 7th 2010


11 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

My favourite Pink Floyd album.

Dragonforce89
April 11th 2010


332 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

WTF 4,5 atleast its should get. If you cant handle long songs thats your problem.

Counterfeit
June 1st 2010


17836 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Pretty good, actually.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy