While She Sleeps   So What?
2.8
good
Release Date: 2019
Tracklist

 Full ReviewRatings (234) Give your Rating

2.5 averageHalez | March 8th 19

That's an insult to All That Remains' "radio rock" material, at least you can remember a good bit of that.

2 Bumps | Bump

2.0 poorVanFullOfSpooks | March 7th 19

This is like how All That Remains went from making The Fall of Ideals to shitty radio rock, its
THAT BAD! Plus their lyrics are so cheesy and laughable at times. Gonna be a yikes for me dawg


2 Bumps | Bump

2.0 poorKars Landman | March 9th 24

They can write two amazing songs with the good sections of this record. Hence the rating.

Bump

3.5 greatSoilworker90 | March 4th 19

It is their weakest output. No question. But still a good one, in my opinion. There are some good songs and some mediocre ones. The production lacks a bit of punch and espacially, more neck-breaking parts like the ending of 'Back of My Mind' are surely missing. I like the message of the album, though, and again, it's not a bad Metalcore album (a bad Metalcore album is BMTH's latest....thing, whatever :D ). So nothing ground-breaking, definitely worse than 'You Are We', but still quite enjoyable. But far aways from a classic, too.

Bump

0.0 zeitgeistaddendum | February 1st 19

I fucking loved You Are We. I find all of their LPs are extremely enjoyable, although not without its flaws. However, I do feel like this one's going to be disappointing. At least, the first two singles of the cycle were disappointing. The third one was meh. So I'm curious what the rest of the record's gonna be like.

Bump

3.5 greatrussischeBergziege | April 18th 24
3.0 goodMikeBG | April 5th 24
2.0 poorSheWatchedTheSky | April 3rd 24
2.5 averageryallen | March 31st 24
3.0 goodPiem | March 13th 24
3.0 goodSixteenSaltines | March 10th 24
2.5 averagetinytim | February 22nd 24
3.0 goodBarksdale | December 16th 23
3.5 greathangth3dj | December 13th 23
2.5 averagebattleinthenorth | September 7th 23
5.0 classicblackspeech | July 22nd 23
2.5 averages0nicx | July 19th 23
2.5 averageEXSCHISM | June 19th 23
3.0 goodboreduser | May 19th 23
1.5 very poorGet Low | April 23rd 23
4.0 excellentIbex02 | March 26th 23
2.5 averagebellovddd | March 21st 23
2.5 averageAdamTheKirk | March 20th 23
2.5 averagebuddymikhailov | January 25th 23
3.5 greatAndreasCorsten | November 1st 22
2.0 poorRpgRiser | September 28th 22
2.5 averageTomcat13 | August 12th 22
2.0 poorinherentkev | August 10th 22
2.0 poorjanunn | July 31st 22
2.5 averageOlegsandr | July 31st 22
3.0 goodVibeymetal | July 12th 22
3.0 goodTheGoni | June 22nd 22
3.5 greatMatty CONTRIBUTOR | June 13th 22
3.5 greattmchugh117 | May 29th 22
3.5 greatVANDERlism | April 18th 22
3.0 goodelry2k | April 11th 22
2.5 averagemigueldemolina | March 19th 22
2.5 averageNoiseByAccident | March 8th 22
2.5 averagejpturk21 | February 17th 22
3.0 goodMarkTheDead | January 23rd 22
2.5 averagedachstheangry | January 3rd 22
2.5 averageYesMaMan11 | December 17th 21
3.0 goodDiProg95 | November 19th 21
3.0 gooddogbonelove | November 5th 21
2.0 poorLilPeep | August 19th 21
2.0 poorRemcheck91 | May 4th 21
2.0 poorStonedManatee | April 21st 21
2.0 poorkarlulol | April 19th 21
4.0 excellentariich | April 17th 21
3.0 goodIleftyspankedU | April 16th 21
3.0 goodOobaloo | April 16th 21
3.5 greatArrestedImpulse | April 13th 21
3.5 greatryank2606 | April 5th 21
1.0 awfulBen STAFF | March 23rd 21
3.5 greatgreyofthedawn | March 17th 21
4.0 excellentPaulski22 | February 21st 21
3.0 goodDylan | February 12th 21
3.5 greatChertran | February 11th 21
2.5 averageLichtmensch | February 9th 21
2.0 poorSwinny93 | February 7th 21
3.5 greatktlilian | January 26th 21
2.0 poortheoleinnout | January 22nd 21
2.5 averagenightlesS | December 30th 20
2.5 averageMyTasteSucks | November 26th 20
2.5 averageMasha2k | November 19th 20
1.5 very poorfathergascoigne | November 14th 20
2.0 poorkatsume1782 | November 14th 20
2.0 pooremptyhanded789 | November 7th 20
2.5 averageKrillBoi | October 5th 20
1.5 very poor3and6vs6and0 | October 4th 20
4.0 excellentGorey13 | August 27th 20
3.0 goodmetalhead97 | July 17th 20
3.0 goodSatelliteYears | July 15th 20
2.0 poor2CHAINAL | June 16th 20
2.0 poorMegaResurrectedJake4 | June 7th 20
2.5 averageJulio Carvajal | May 17th 20
4.0 excellentXeno2014 | May 12th 20
2.5 averageMatthewD333 | May 4th 20
2.5 averagekillbot2000 | April 30th 20
3.5 greatAlex Bourret | April 25th 20
2.5 averageDavidPrincipe29 | April 25th 20
3.0 goodInAndOfItSelf | April 24th 20
3.0 goodMrHahaHihi | April 22nd 20
3.0 gooddrcaramel | April 13th 20
3.0 goodMichichachi | March 26th 20
2.5 averageFaketushka | March 22nd 20
3.0 gooddjentist8 | February 29th 20
3.5 greatcharlie15 | February 14th 20
3.0 goodfurkhanayd | February 12th 20
2.0 poorbenny06 | February 10th 20
4.0 excellentIsn0gud | February 5th 20
1.5 very poorOmeggia | January 4th 20
3.0 goodforshoredividesusger | January 4th 20
3.5 greatthesickness | December 28th 19
2.5 averagethybathory | December 17th 19
3.5 greattcrazyknuckles | December 13th 19
2.5 averageNorwichScene | December 6th 19
2.0 poormEyck07 | November 22nd 19
4.0 excellentAmbrisa | November 19th 19
3.0 goodSTEA | November 17th 19
3.5 greatDATO | November 12th 19
3.5 greatDarkInfernal | November 4th 19
3.5 greatchaz1254 | October 24th 19
3.0 goodHirokin | October 17th 19
3.5 greatgrizzlys54 | October 7th 19
3.5 greatRenée | October 7th 19
3.5 greatShane Ryan | October 2nd 19
3.0 goodAdrianQuinn | September 30th 19
1.5 very poorHanusko | September 22nd 19
2.0 poorMateo Ottie CONTRIBUTOR | September 19th 19
4.0 excellentDelre57 | September 16th 19
3.5 greatUzumaki | August 23rd 19
3.5 greatJaxer | August 23rd 19
2.0 poorReviewc0re | August 16th 19
2.5 averageMacck | August 9th 19
2.0 poorAlain0393 | August 5th 19
4.5 superbHybridF | July 23rd 19
2.5 averageTrey STAFF | July 6th 19
2.0 poorPikazilla | June 18th 19
3.0 goodjosh | June 10th 19
5.0 classicnsarver | May 29th 19
2.0 poorlatpac | May 23rd 19
5.0 classicbrodway2 | May 20th 19
3.0 goodbrunch | May 20th 19
3.5 greathadriel | May 10th 19
5.0 classicmikejulian222 | May 7th 19
1.5 very poorMythoBeanz69 | April 16th 19
1.5 very poorLasernair | April 14th 19
4.5 superbfaitedecicatrices | April 14th 19
2.5 averagewadledee12 | April 14th 19
2.0 poorSpicyPikachu1 | April 11th 19
2.5 averageutahman1971 | April 10th 19
2.0 poorginnungagap | April 6th 19
3.5 greatChris Maitland | April 4th 19
2.5 averageDiabetes | April 2nd 19
2.0 poorIceDoesntHelp | March 29th 19
4.0 excellentDoomstercry | March 28th 19
3.0 goodresident sputbirb with fancy hat | March 24th 19
3.0 goodMattallica | March 21st 19
3.5 greatEldave93 | March 21st 19
3.5 greatTheSupernatural | March 21st 19
2.5 averageMuppelope | March 17th 19
3.0 goodAnanasins | March 15th 19
4.0 excellentGregoriusV | March 14th 19
1.5 very poorBreakfastCat | March 13th 19
3.0 goodProPrayer | March 12th 19
3.0 goodBeardedBird | March 12th 19
1.0 awfulHidekiMaki9 | March 11th 19
2.0 poorjesper STAFF | March 11th 19
2.5 averagemayesaman2 | March 11th 19
3.0 goodfuryroad97 | March 10th 19
3.0 goodiamSeraph | March 8th 19
2.5 averagepeartnoy | March 8th 19
2.5 averagejmh886 | March 8th 19
3.0 goodAcole9 | March 7th 19
2.0 poorTranqyl | March 7th 19
4.5 superbMetalcoreGodzilla | March 7th 19
3.5 greatmetalhead | March 7th 19
3.0 goodsebchando | March 6th 19
2.5 averageYour #1 Most Loved Semiaquatic, Egg-Laying Mammal | March 6th 19
1.5 very poorElynna | March 6th 19
2.5 averageAlviro99 | March 6th 19
2.0 pooroutliers | March 6th 19
2.0 poorzeitgeistaddendum2 | March 6th 19
2.5 averageellagos | March 6th 19
3.0 goodZombieParty | March 6th 19
3.0 goodLefondre | March 5th 19
3.0 goodKlingel0905 | March 5th 19
2.5 averageKrissWatts | March 5th 19
2.5 averageAmbushReality | March 5th 19
3.5 greatem17ah | March 5th 19
2.5 averagePyramidNoise | March 5th 19
2.0 poormirak2 | March 5th 19
2.0 poorCthulhuFhtagn | March 4th 19
2.5 averagevinylman35 | March 4th 19
3.5 greatacmolan | March 4th 19
1.5 very poormikep87 | March 4th 19
2.5 averagesuppatime | March 4th 19
3.0 goodAsura14 | March 4th 19
1.5 very poorfrozencarl | March 4th 19
2.0 poorNine | March 4th 19
2.0 poorErwann S. STAFF | March 4th 19
2.5 averageRumpelkombo | March 3rd 19
3.0 goodNordicNorth | March 3rd 19
3.5 greatJoe_turner10 | March 3rd 19
2.0 poormadtwoo | March 3rd 19
4.0 excellentNonApplicable | March 3rd 19
2.0 poorSimon K. STAFF | March 2nd 19
5.0 classicBeardedBear | March 2nd 19
4.5 superbLittleBitOfEverythin | March 2nd 19
3.5 greatSYL | March 2nd 19
4.5 superbMcGuire95 | March 2nd 19
2.5 averageInFlamesWeThrash666 | March 2nd 19
5.0 classicleolhc | March 2nd 19
2.5 averageTristan Matheny | March 2nd 19
1.5 very poorAdoreSwancore | March 2nd 19
3.0 goodStephenMusic | March 2nd 19
2.5 averageheck | March 2nd 19
3.0 goodFaraudo | March 2nd 19
2.5 averageCaliggyJack | March 2nd 19
1.0 awfulDoctuses | March 1st 19
3.0 goodkman123 | March 1st 19
3.5 greatyourmindsdecide | March 1st 19
5.0 classicanish23061956 | March 1st 19
2.5 averageCherryChase | March 1st 19
2.0 poorBleedIntoTheAbyss | March 1st 19
2.0 poorProject | March 1st 19
2.5 averageMysticore | March 1st 19
3.0 goodItsTheSquirrel | March 1st 19
4.0 excellentMarek | March 1st 19
2.5 averagegilly | March 1st 19
3.0 goodToondude | March 1st 19
2.5 averagebuttgrinder | March 1st 19
4.0 excellentcrystanmoth | March 1st 19
2.5 averageT5Cx | March 1st 19
3.0 goodLineman | March 1st 19
2.5 averageScheumke | March 1st 19
2.5 averageSlothy Seconds | March 1st 19
2.0 poorEl Olam | March 1st 19
3.0 goodJosh | March 1st 19
3.0 goodMrToothbrush | March 1st 19
2.5 averageMrGentleCat | February 28th 19
1.5 very poorMatthias812 | February 28th 19
4.0 excellentslayerofthegods | February 26th 19
3.0 goodpinkgengar | February 26th 19
4.0 excellentBillClinton | February 25th 19
4.5 superbzzf1918 | February 25th 19
2.5 averageEagleOwl | February 24th 19
4.0 excellentterriblekonrad | February 24th 19
1.5 very poorChamberbelain | February 24th 19
3.5 greatsplinter | February 24th 19
2.5 averageDORBUSCUS | February 24th 19
1.5 very poorExhaleTheLight | February 23rd 19
4.0 excellentklocu4 | February 2nd 19
3.0 goodWrath2016 | January 7th 19

Give Your Opinion on So What?


You have to be logged in to rate this album Login | Create a Profile

STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy