Brabiz
07.16.23 | Not a big fan of Metallica, but I still try to listen every now and then hoping it clicks for me. |
bellovddd
07.16.23 | tripping yo. |
Goodolboy
07.16.23 | "Personally hate Disposable Heroes"
Smh |
Emim
07.16.23 | 2,4,3,5, who cares |
Feather
07.16.23 | This is the first time I’m listening to death magnetic as a result of this list. Hope you’re happy with yourself |
sneakers
07.17.23 | Wowzers! |
Brabiz
07.17.23 | Disposable Heroes is lame |
Eakflanderyof
07.17.23 | Definitely one of the most interesting metallica rankings I've seen. Agreed that 72 seasons overrated though and is definitely at least bottom 3 in their discog |
BAT
07.17.23 | at one point i'd put masters, at another ride the lightning. but now i'd probably go with kill em all as best metallica.
honestly haven't heard death magnetic in over 15 years, should probably give it a spin |
Emim
07.17.23 | Disposable Heroes is so good though |
ToSmokMuzyki
07.17.23 | kill em all and then a range of okays to total embarassments |
bellovddd
07.17.23 | master is my fav Metallica album, followed by Ride and Justice then the rest. |
mrdogthrow
07.17.23 | stoopid band |
evilford
07.17.23 | Featured hahah |
Brabiz
07.17.23 | Death magnetic is the only one I personally love tbh, so it’ll always be my 1. This band is so boring to me as a whole |
Brabiz
07.17.23 | Creeping death is the band’s best track tho I’d say |
Koris
07.17.23 | "Personally hate Disposable Heroes"
Literally my favorite Metallica song lol |
pizzamachine
07.17.23 | Got em |
Wildcardbitchesss
07.17.23 | 72 Seasons ain’t great but it’s certainly not worse than Load or Reload. Actually agree with the St Anger ranking. It’s not good but at least there’s some fucking passion behind it.
And Death Magnetic rules but damn number 1? That’s a spicy take |
Eakflanderyof
07.17.23 | I'll personally take load and reload all day over 72 seasons. Load and reload at least have some personality |
EoinCofa
07.17.23 | Some people take loads |
Dwap
07.17.23 | Terrible ranking |
Icebloom
07.17.23 | Back to the frrront! |
Tundra
07.17.23 | DM underrated, maybe not the best, but its damn good |
FrozenFirebug
07.17.23 | agreeable list if you switch s/t/ and kill em all |
Brabiz
07.17.23 | “ 72 Seasons ain’t great but it’s certainly not worse than Load or Reload.” both of those albums at least were a band changing up their sound and trying something new. 72 Seasons is aggressively stale and performative. They’re just going through the motions and refusing to do anything creative or interesting. It’s not a shit show, but I wish it was, then it would at least be interesting |
hangth3dj
07.17.23 | Good to see Reload correctly being ranked higher than Load. |
Stakaline
07.17.23 | Lulu is 1 |
Brabiz
07.17.23 | Lulu is unironically more interesting than 72 Seasons |
Wildcardbitchesss
07.18.23 | that I agree with.
It might actually be better too lmfao. I haven’t heard it in a fucking decade tho |
brendanissnaz
07.18.23 | Respect for DM at number one, my second favorite after AJFA |
ToSmokMuzyki
07.18.23 | SPERMLESS LIKE A GIRRRRLLL |
Brabiz
07.18.23 | “Terrible ranking”
No, terrible band |
Butkuiss
07.19.23 | The Black Album unironically rips so hard. Criminal to rank it so low. It’s where Metallica finally threw off the shackles of uninspired noodling and finally started writing good pop songs. |
evilford
07.19.23 | Uhhh lol |
Brabiz
07.19.23 | I wish they were uninspired noodling. Band is just thrash with butt rock vibes. Black album is just butt rock |
Gavierra
07.20.23 | Lulu > this ranking |
Kusangii
07.20.23 | I think DM is underrated too but having it at #1 is really interesting |
deathschool
07.20.23 | 3 and 2 are 1 and 2. They're also the only Metallica albums I would choose to listen to in 2023. Death Magnetic is lolbad. The fact that people still act like it's a good album just because it manages to not be worse than St. Anger really sets a a bar so low that it's underground. |
deathschool
07.20.23 | Why is this featured lol |
Hawks
07.20.23 | 2, 4, 5, 3, 8. Fuck the rest. |
DoofDoof
07.20.23 | 12 is maybe better than 1
funny |
Eakflanderyof
07.20.23 | 12 is 11 |
Brabiz
07.20.23 | “12 is maybe better than 1”
Eat the slop then. |
Brabiz
07.20.23 | “I think DM is underrated too but having it at #1 is really interesting”
Idk why it’s interesting. Even DM isn’t anything special. I just like it more than the other stuff. This band is agonizing to listen to for more than 30 minutes |
DoofDoof
07.20.23 | they sound real similar but the production is better on 12 and I'd say the overall song writing consistency is better.
1 has a few songs maybe better than any on 12.
So to say they are so far apart seems like grasping but hey, personal taste and all that |
Brabiz
07.20.23 | I just think they have such a similar sound, while 12 is considerably more watered down. I cant remember a single riff off it. It sounds like a more generic Hardwired. Which, this late in their career is kind of sad. Feels like they’re just doing it for the money and nothing else. |
Eakflanderyof
07.20.23 | Death magnetic was the last album where I didn't feel like I stopped paying attention halfway through because it was so uninteresting |
Brabiz
07.22.23 | Okay i don’t hate Disposable Heroes anymore. I am at a point of feeling indifferent about it. Not better than the debut though. |
Brabiz
07.22.23 | 72 Seasons is just utterly worthless to me. People can say “it’s not that bad” ad infinitum, but it feels so cynical and lifeless that whenever I hear it, it feels insulting. Especially at the runtime it has. |
AlexKzillion
07.22.23 | switch 11 and 1 and I'm in |
Brabiz
07.22.23 | Fuck yeah, hoss |
Zig
07.22.23 | lulu is #1 |
Gavierra
07.26.23 | agreed |