WhiteWallStargazers
11.08.11 | Curious to hear people's thoughts :) |
mvood
11.08.11 | Only band I've been close to 5'ing more than one of their discography was The National |
SmokingTheClouds
11.08.11 | I personally only like to 5 a single album per band. But that's just me. I don't 5 things all too often.
Also, fuck yeah #4! |
WhiteWallStargazers
11.08.11 | Yeah I try to keep it to one 5 per band generally. |
zxlkho
11.08.11 | If an album is a 5, it's a 5. Everyone just likes to complicate things. |
Colliiiin
11.08.11 | ^
What this guy said, also fuck yeah for 4 almost wanted to 5 it myself. |
Trebor.
11.08.11 | I have two for Radiohead and two for Streetlight Manifesto
|
Cipieron
11.08.11 | 4 is borderline between 4.5-5 for me. if i had to give just ONE instrumental album a 5 it would be The Collective... but something is holding me back from bumping it up |
bloc
11.08.11 | Hell, I have tons of artists with multiple 5's
As long as not EVERY single release on the band's page is a 5, you should be okay. |
Aids
11.08.11 | "If an album is a 5, it's a 5. Everyone just likes to complicate things."
this. Pink Floyd, The Beatles, The National, Manchester Orchestra, and La Dispute all have multiple 5s for me. I mean, how can you choose just one 5 for Animals, DSOTM, Wish You Were Here, The Wall. impossible. |
dammets
11.08.11 | I disagree with the words that go with the ratings. A 5 isn't a "classic" It's just an amazing album. And I wouldn't give a "good" album a 3. A three is an "ok" album. That's just me. |
Aids
11.08.11 | "I have two for Radiohead and two for Streetlight Manifesto"
Trebor, dude. Dude. I just got into Streetlight Manifesto (Everything Goes Numb is my newest 5) they fucking RULE. I mean, I thought I didn't really like ska but now I don't know man. I've been obsessing over them for a week straight. |
taxidermist
11.08.11 | I have 2 AtD-I releases 5'd. Might become like 3 or 4 in time, lol. Love that band. |
dammets
11.08.11 | I have three Tool 5's -_- |
bloc
11.08.11 | "I disagree with the words that go with the ratings."
Agreed 100%
I mean a 3/5 is "Good" but it's also 60% which is a pretty low score. |
Aids
11.08.11 | "I disagree with the words that go with the ratings. A 5 isn't a "classic" It's just an amazing album. And I wouldn't give a "good" album a 3. A three is an "ok" album. That's just me."
yeah, also this. I like the system better at rym where you can assign your own classifiers for ratings. |
foxblood
11.08.11 | i just 5 records that are really important to me, regardless of how many 5's the band has. i mean there's no way i could 5 only one Springsteen album |
foxblood
11.08.11 | also WhiteWall, i'm curious as to why you 1'd 8 of the beatles albums, you really hate them that much? |
zxlkho
11.08.11 | >only 5's 1 album per band
>1's 8 Beatles albums
>wat |
coneren
11.08.11 | he is a penis zx |
zxlkho
11.08.11 | orly |
InAbsentia
11.08.11 | It would be impossible for me to five less than 3 Godspeed albums. And BwP and Still Life both deserve a 5. So as much as I
try giving a five to no more than one album per band, sometimes an exception has to be made.
Also, I, too, had the Kid A dilemma a few days ago. I ended up fiving it. Couldn't see a reason why not. |
clercqie
11.08.11 | Radiohead and dEUS - 3 5's
Arcade Fire, Bruce Springsteen, The Jam, The Clash and The Rolling Stones - 2 5's
So yeah... :p
|
zxlkho
11.08.11 | Radiohead should not have a 5. |
Aids
11.08.11 | "It would be impossible for me to five less than 3 Godspeed albums."
ahhh shit how did I forget my favourite band when I was listing the ones I had given multiple 5s to? yeah, they have three undeniable 5s. |
zxlkho
11.08.11 | F#A#, Slow Riot, and Skinny Fists correct? If you 5 Yanqui lolu. |
InAbsentia
11.08.11 | Yeah. |
InAbsentia
11.08.11 | I'm also on the fence about giving In Rainbows a 5. It's just that good IMO. Radiohead deserve all the praise they get. |
zxlkho
11.08.11 | To me, Radiohead is like The Beatles, Neutral Milk Hotel, and Devin Townsend.
I just don't fucking understand them. |
WhiteWallStargazers
11.08.11 | I 1'd the beatles as a joke, I actually love the beatles |
InAbsentia
11.08.11 | I agree with you on the Beatles and Devin Townsend, but In The Aeroplane... is a masterpiece. |
zxlkho
11.08.11 | I've listened to it 10+ times and still don't get how anyone thinks that. |
InAbsentia
11.08.11 | @ WhiteWall: how come your ratings weren't erased? |
zxlkho
11.08.11 | I guess it's just like how you don't think The Devil and God... is a masterpiece. lol |
InAbsentia
11.08.11 | Exactly what I was going to say. |
WhiteWallStargazers
11.08.11 | @InAbsentia: I have no idea why my ratings weren't erased. Though it was way before the Great Ratings Purge of 2011 |
Aids
11.08.11 | "I 1'd the beatles as a joke, I actually love the beatles"
thank moses i was about to e-rage |
