RTCW: | Sputnikmusic

Jasdevi087 05.19.14	Agreed hard for 1 even though I've only heard 1 and 5. But surely 1 is 1.
RTCW 05.19.14	Any of my top 4 could have made it to #1 but I never tire of listening to LS so that's why it made the top spot
Snake. 05.19.14	is this kill
ChoccyPhilly 05.19.14	Deadwing is 1 all the way. Can't believe it's so low on this list
Verm 05.19.14	8 is too low
RTCW 05.19.14	Deadwing will never be close to top #5 for me. It's one of those albums that you will enjoy a lot when you first start getting into PT but after that it's kinda meh. Halo, Shallow and Lazarus are mostly terrible and while the other songs are pretty good, Deadwing is just no where near as strong as the rest of the discography. The fact that it is also their worst when it comes to sound quality doesn't help either
Artuma 05.19.14	1 is 1 and 8 is too low yea arriving somewhere is their best song dude
RTCW 05.19.14	Not for me. I prefer at least one song from each album aside from Sunday, The Incident and Deadwing over Arriving Somewhere
ChoccyPhilly 05.19.14	What's wrong with the sound quality on Deadwing? Whilst I can admit that shallow and Halo are a bit meh at times, lazarus and the rest of the album is gorgeous especially the bridge of start of something beautiful. You're not gonna get a more beautiful moment from PT in any other album. Also is the incident really worse than on the sunday of life? It wasn't great but surely it wasn't as bad as 9...
RTCW 05.19.14	Deadwing is brickwalled to shit. I actually quite like Deadwing - it's just that I rate their other stuff much higher and it also has a couple of my least favourite PT songs. Sunday of Life is very good in places imo but it just has way too much filler. I really can't get into The Incident at all but it has its moments
Emyay 05.19.14	good list kill. i'd have 5/6/8 higher but i can get behind this.
Onirium 05.19.14	How could you possibly prefer 9 to 10? I mean, yeah, 10 is really not their best, but 9 is nothing except for Radioactive Toy. And yeah, Deadwing is top 3 imo
RTCW 05.19.14	I like Sunday because of its quirkiness and songs like Jupiter Island, Nine Cats, Radioactive Toy, The Nostalgia Factory, It Will Rain for a Million years to name a few are good.
KILL 05.19.14	has a max payne pic must be me! gd rank 7 is way higher i reckon
Onirium 05.19.14	Btw, nice to see In Absentia ranked correctly, I find it so overrated
Emyay 05.19.14	i like this list bc it gives both old pt and new pt love. my personal list would have all of the newer stuff ranked highest, but its cool to see someone who appreciates both eras
KILL 05.19.14	lol yea thats so rare wow
benkim 05.19.14	Still need to listen to 3 but IA and Deadwing are a bit too low man.
TalonsOfFire 05.19.14	8 is 1, 5 is 2, 6 is 3
KILL 05.19.14	most typical opinion ever talons gj
Onirium 05.19.14	Signify is 1 though
RTCW 05.19.14	I was thinking of putting Up the Downstair above IA and Fear and also Signify higher but they are all so good...
Onirium 05.19.14	Yeah they're all at least 3.5s (except Sunday which is a 3)
JamieTwort 05.19.14	At least you got 10 in the right place. 3 and 7 are their best and then 4 which is alright, fuck the rest.
KILL 05.19.14	dont you dig some stuff on sunday jamie? some of the stuff is similar to up the downstair
JamieTwort 05.19.14	I hardly ever listen to it tbh, can't even remember most of it. Radiocative Toy's good from what I remember and I like the version of Nine Cats from the Signify outtakes disc.
Emyay 05.19.14	sunday and downstair are both terrible
JamieTwort 05.19.14	lol ok.
KILL 05.19.14	emturd
JamieTwort 05.19.14	I'm not gonna argue about Sunday cos I don't even remember it (not even sure if I've listened to it in it's entirety) but Downstair is some great trippy psych and pretty much the best music Wilson ever recorded!
RTCW 05.19.14	"sunday and downstair are both terrible" Give Downstair some more listens then it will click
KILL 05.19.14	not enough lyrics about xbox's for emyay
Emyay 05.19.14	not enough good music
KerfuffleinaHussle 05.19.14	sunday is like 70% pointless shit how can it be better than the incident
Emyay 05.19.14	its not
KILL 05.19.14	theyre both about tied for me, radioactive toy rapes anything on the incident
Emyay 05.19.14	i drive the hearse is a better song
KILL 05.19.14	no that song does have a great solo though
Emyay 05.19.14	radioactive toy is aight but i don't really see why its highly regarded. its basically just a dumb verse followed by some wanking, repeat
KILL 05.19.14	wow
ChoccyPhilly 05.19.14	Everything from Octane Twisted to I Drive The Hearse is great and The Incident is by far more consistent than On The Sunday Of Life
conesmoke 05.19.14	Wtf is this ranking.. Wtf man?
KILL 05.19.14	its slightly more consistent but the highs are higher! and its not like the incident doesnt have some terrible songs cmon
Emyay 05.19.14	incident has some terrible songs but sunday is one big long cringe fest
ChoccyPhilly 05.19.14	Ok, drawing the line maybe, but it's equally bad as jupiter planet or whatever it's called. Doesn't get any higher than I Drive The Hearse. Beautiful stuff...
conesmoke 05.19.14	Oath, but incident has its stunning moments
KILL 05.19.14	sunday has many great moments, especially if ur into psych
ChoccyPhilly 05.19.14	sunday is one big long cringe fest [2]
KILL 05.19.14	bet u bitches havent even heard the pretty things
RTCW 05.19.14	Only if you take it seriously
conesmoke 05.19.14	I drive the hearse is top 10 pt
KILL 05.19.14	top 50 maybe
JohnnyoftheWell 05.19.14	Deadwing needs to be higher, otherwise cool
conesmoke 05.19.14	lol kill you the man, just like ck is
conesmoke 05.19.14	Don't let insecurities matter. The duck does Mozart care if I post or not. And he slayed music harder than anyone... Ever... Ever!
conesmoke 05.19.14	Lol the duck haha
JamieTwort 05.19.14	"sunday is like 70% pointless shit how can it be better than the incident" Because The Incident is like 90% dog shit.
Necrotica 05.19.14	The Incident is way better than Sunday imo
BigPleb 05.19.14	both suck
Necrotica 05.19.14	Sunday's my least favorite but I still gave it a 3
Emyay 05.19.14	about to listen to up the downstair again. i'd listen to sunday but i share an office with a dude and play music on my speakers. don't want to look like an a-hole
ChoccyPhilly 05.19.14	Linton Samuel Dawson the shit out of those speakers